Conversation and Responsibility by Michael McKenna

By Michael McKenna

during this publication Michael McKenna advances a brand new idea of ethical accountability, one who builds upon the paintings of P. F. Strawson. As McKenna demonstrates, ethical accountability could be defined on analogy with a talk. The relation among a morally in charge agent and people who carry her morally liable is the same to the relation among a speaker and her viewers. A accountable agent's activities are bearers of meaning--agent meaning--just as a speaker's utterances are bearers of speaker which means. Agent that means is a functionality of the ethical caliber of the need with which the agent acts. those that carry an agent morally accountable for what she does achieve this by way of responding to her as though in a talk. through responding with definite morally reactive attitudes, corresponding to resentment or indignation, they thereby converse their regard for the that means taken to be printed in that agent's activities. it truly is then open for the agent held in charge to reply to these keeping her in charge via providing an apology, a justification, an excuse, or another reaction, thereby extending the evolving conversational exchange.

The conversational thought of ethical accountability that McKenna develops right here accepts good points of Strawson's idea: that ethical accountability is basically interpersonal--so that being dependable needs to be understood by way of connection with the character of protecting responsible--and that the ethical feelings are principal to maintaining liable. whereas upholding those features of Strawson's concept, McKenna's thought rejects a different Strawsonian thesis, that is that preserving morally in charge is extra primary or uncomplicated than being morally liable. at the conversational idea, the stipulations for containing accountable are depending on the character of the agent who's accountable. So retaining in charge can't be extra simple than being accountable. however, the character of the agent who's morally in charge is to be understood when it comes to sensitivity to people who might make ethical calls for of her, thereby maintaining her dependable. Being accountable is as a result additionally depending on maintaining liable. hence, neither being nor keeping morally accountable is extra uncomplicated than the opposite. they're collectively dependent.

Show description

Read Online or Download Conversation and Responsibility PDF

Similar ethics & morality books

Razones Para Actuar. Una Teoría del Libre Albedrío (Colección Jovellanos de Ensayo nº 21) (Spanish Edition)

There's a classical version of rational motion that has ruled Western highbrow tradition and, not less than again to Aristotle, in keeping with which deliberation is usually approximately potential and not approximately ends. Its common extension is mirrored in either Hume's declare that "Reason is and should be a slave of the passions", as within the appreciation of Kant that "Whoever wishes the top wishes the capacity.

Values For A New Millennium: Activating the Natural Law to: Reduce Violence, Revitalize Our Schools, and Promote Cross-Cultural Harmony

Robert L. Humphrey was once an Iwo Jima veteran, Harvard graduate, and move cultural clash answer professional in the course of the chilly warfare. He proposed the "Dual existence worth concept" of Human Nature. From the reviews of youth within the nice melancholy, journeys as within the Panamanian service provider Marines, national-class boxing, the awe-inspiring points of interest of selfless sacrifice on Iwo Jima, and at last, fifteen years in out of the country ideological conflict, Humphrey saw that common values exist and, finally keep watch over human habit.

Moral Responsibility and the Problem of Many Hands (Routledge Studies in Ethics and Moral Theory)

Whilst many folks are serious about an task, it's always tough, if now not most unlikely, to pinpoint who's morally accountable for what, a phenomenon often called the ‘problem of many fingers. ’ This time period is more and more used to explain issues of attributing person accountability in collective settings in such varied components as public management, company administration, legislation and legislation, technological improvement and innovation, healthcare, and finance.

The Future of Meat Without Animals (Future Perfect: Images of the Time to Come in Philosophy, Politics and Cultural Studies)

Plant-based and cell-cultured meat, milk, and egg manufacturers goal to exchange commercial nutrition construction with animal-free fare that tastes larger, charges much less, and calls for a fragment of the power inputs. those items aren't any longer relegated to area of interest markets for moral vegetarians, yet are seriously funded by way of deepest traders having a bet on meat with out animals as mass-market, environmentally possible choices that may be scaled for a turning out to be worldwide inhabitants.

Additional info for Conversation and Responsibility

Sample text

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.17 of 5 – based on 32 votes