Meta-metaphysics: On Metaphysical Equivalence, by Jiri Benovsky

By Jiri Benovsky

Metaphysical theories are attractive. on the finish of this ebook, Jiri Benovsky defends the view that metaphysical theories own aesthetic houses and that those play an important position in terms of idea assessment and idea choice.
Before we get there, the philosophical direction the writer proposes to persist with begins with 3 discussions of metaphysical equivalence. Benovsky argues that there are instances of metaphysical equivalence, situations of partial metaphysical equivalence, in addition to fascinating circumstances of theories that aren't identical. therefore, claims of metaphysical equivalence can in basic terms be raised in the neighborhood. The slogan is: easy methods to do meta-metaphysics is to do first-level metaphysics.To do that paintings, Benovsky makes a speciality of the character of primitives and at the function they play in all the theories concerned. He emphasizes the maximum value of primitives within the building of metaphysical theories and within the next evaluate of them.
He then increases the easy yet complex query: easy methods to make a selection among competing metaphysical theories? If theories are identical, then maybe we don't have the desire to make a call. yet what approximately the entire different circumstances of non-equivalent "equally solid" theories? Benovsky makes use of the various theories mentioned within the first a part of the ebook as examples and examines a few conventional meta-theoretical standards for thought selection (various different types of simplicity, compatibility with physics, compatibility with intuitions, explanatory energy, inner consistency,...) in basic terms to teach that they don't let us make a choice.
But if the normal meta-theoretical standards can't support us in identifying among competing non-equivalent metaphysical theories, how then lets make that selection? this can be the place Benovsky argues that metaphysical theories own aesthetic homes – grounded in non-aesthetic houses – and that those play a vital function in idea selection and assessment. This view, in addition to all of the meta-metaphysical issues mentioned through the publication, then clearly lead the writer to a sort of anti-realism, and on the finish of the adventure he deals purposes to imagine best of the type of anti-realist view he proposes to embrace.

Show description

Read or Download Meta-metaphysics: On Metaphysical Equivalence, Primitiveness, and Theory Choice (Synthese Library) PDF

Similar metaphysics books

Closure: A Story of Everything

For over 2000 years our tradition has believed within the chance of a unmarried actual account of the realm. Now this age is coming to a detailed. therefore there's a deep unease. we're misplaced either as contributors, and as a tradition. within the new relativistic, post-modern period, we haven't any background, no correct or ethical motion, and no physique of data.

Trinitarian Wisdom - The Art of Life

Are we dwelling in a very smart or uncivilized civilization? Why is our civilization ruled by means of egoism and never altruism to optimize our collective intelligence? Are we actually clever sufficient to resolve—if we don't jeopardize it all—the worldwide and humanitarian difficulties and salvage our ill-ridden nature?

Space and Time: A Priori and A Posteriori Studies (Philosophische Analyse / Philosophical Analysis)

This assortment makes a speciality of the ontology of house and time. it's targeted at the concept that the problems in most cases encountered during this sector has to be tackled from a multifarious standpoint, taking note of either a priori and a posteriori issues. a number of specialists during this quarter give a contribution to this volume:G.

The Writings of Charles De Koninck: Volume 2

The Writings of Charles De Koninck, Volumes 1 and a couple of, current the 1st English variations of the amassed works of the Catholic Thomist thinker Charles De Koninck (1906–1965). Ralph McInerny (1929–2010) used to be the venture editor and ready the superb translations. quantity 2 starts off with works released in 1943: Ego Sapientia: The knowledge that's Mary, De Koninck's first learn in Mariology, and The Primacy of the typical sturdy opposed to the Personalists (with the main of the hot Order), which generated a robust serious response.

Extra info for Meta-metaphysics: On Metaphysical Equivalence, Primitiveness, and Theory Choice (Synthese Library)

Example text

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.05 of 5 – based on 7 votes